Yesterday venture capitalist Josh Kopelman unleashed a diatribe ripping into MySpace and praising Facebook for the recent move to open up and become a platform for widget developers. Kopelman estimates there there has been $250 million dollars invested into widget companies over the past year and a half, but because of MySpace"s tepid relationship with widget creators, he says, it"s a no-brainer to choose Facebook as a focus for your development efforts.
Think about it. If you ran a venture-backed company and had to decide whether you wanted to focus your effort on: (a) a property that welcomed you in and let you keep 100% of the revenue you generate or (b) a company with a vague policy that doesn’t let you generate any revenue, which would you choose? I don’t think it’s even a decision. It’s an IQ test.
MySpace"s icy demeanor toward widget creators, and their indecision on how to handle them, created a huge opportunity for Facebook, according to Kopelman. "Facebook has just increased it’s [sic] virtual R&D budget by over $250 million dollars," he writes.
Mike Arrington agrees with Kopelman, pointing out that even though MySpace still dwarfs Facebook in size (100 million users vs. 20 million), and is growing faster, Facebook"s openness toward widget creators should be very attractive to them. "Startups can build a very large business on the back of Facebook. The MySpace path is much riskier," he says.
I agree that Facebook made a brilliant move last week by opening up their network and embracing third-party developers. They may well have just leap-frogged MySpace by providing an environment that encourages developers to make Facebook more useful for its users. While nothing too compelling has been created so far (though iLike"s Facebook application has an impressive 482,000 users in its first weekend), all it takes is one killer app on the Facebook platform to really start drawing in the users and catch up to MySpace.
The move will certainly encourage developers to create applications for Facebook, and it might inspire some people to develop companies specifically around Facebook. The chances that that killer app will be created have increased. But, I don"t think it will necessarily hurt the MySpace widget ecosystem. The barrier for entry in creating a widget is so low that there"s really no reason not to develop your widget on as many platforms as possible. It costs virtually nothing to create a widget, and if your goal is attracting users, then spreading your widget around makes sense.
For the majority of widget creators, the service isn"t the widget, but rather the widget ties into the service. Last.fm, Photobucket, iLike, and Flixster, for example, are all services outside of their widgets. These companies are all likely to offer their users the ability to access their service via as many entry points as possible. Widgets on multiple networks also increases the likelihood that they attract new users.
Certainly, a little less frostiness toward widgets by MySpace, and dare we dream, an API, would help even the playing field, but the Facebook platform is not a death sentence for MySpace widgets. Widget companies collectively breathed a sigh of relief last Thursday: they all of a sudden had access to another 20 million users and from a company that was welcoming them with open arms. But they"re not going to abandon the 100 million users they were already serving at MySpace. Widgets will continue to flourish wherever there are users.
Kopelman compares MySpace to Prodigy and AOL in the early days of the world wide web.
This brings back memories from the early days of the Internet, when companies like Prodigy and AOL were the only online services in town. Despite the launch of the web browser (which unleashed the creation of millions of web sites), AOL and Prodigy initially focused on maintaining their proprietary online environment and controlling everything on their site. It took a few years, but ultimately they saw that it is impossible for one company -- no matter how popular and well-funded -- to compete with an unlimited army of motivated (and funded) developer.
Last Thursday, while I watching the Facebook platform announcement unfold, I too thought of Prodigy and AOL, but my comparison went the other way. Facebook, like any other platform, is the entry point for every app that runs on top of it, which in a way makes them similar to the Prodigy of old. Developers, however, will go where the users are, and users are increasingly demanding that they be able to consume content and services wherever that happens to be. It follows, then, that as long as MySpace is popular with users, it will be popular with widget creators.
>>Source Link
>>Blog: Read/WriteWeb
>>Publish Date: 5/29/2007 8:00:51 AM
>>Keywords: facebook widget
Related Posts
>>Facebook Platform: The Road to IPO? #
This week the Wall Street journal published an excellent piece on the upcoming Facebook Platform, which Josh also covered for Read/WriteWeb. The WSJ article outlined a Facebook platform that will allo
>>Facebook Getting Spacey? #
According to an article in the Wall Street Journal today, social networking site Facebook will announce later this week that it is opening inward (my term, not theirs) and allowing "other companies p
>>Who Can Compete with Facebook? #
I"ve been thinking a lot about the Facebook Platform (who hasn"t?), and about who is in the best position to take them on. The obvious answer is MySpace, still the giant of the social networking world
>>FaceBook已集成Meebome #
这两天，随着Facebook F8的推出，可集成到Facebook中的第三方应用程序越来越多，前面我就介绍过Twitter及Box.net这两款我常用的服务已有了Facebook App应用。... 继续.
>>在Facebook中使用Box.net #
之前我为大家介绍了Twitter发布了Facebook App，同时还说正有更多的第三方应用被集成到FaceBook中。确实，这些第三方服务的开发速度也的确非常快，就在写完上面这篇文章后，发现在Box.net也已通告说他们发布了Box.net Facebook App，同时发现Hung也对做了相应的报道。... 继续.
>>FaceBook集成了Picnik #
TC上介绍说FaceBook集成了在线图像编辑软件Picnik，利用Flash技术构建，个人感觉这是一款非常不错的服务。其实在Facebook F8平台推出之时，该款服务就已集成了。用户可以通过该链接把这款工具添加到自已的FaceBook帐号中。... 继续.
>>Yahoo! Widget官方网站全新改版－－炫酷视界,用心诠释 #
作者:雅虎个人软件运营组 新版的Yahoo! Widget官方网站于2007年2月28日正式上线,诚邀各位试用体验. 纵观这次的改版,主要在以下几个方面进行了改进: 一.导航分类紧凑明晰. 针对老版网站导航栏目较分散的情况进行了改进,将Widget开发相关和用户交流的栏目进行了合并调整.调整后的导航和具体页面的内容分布更符合用户的使用习惯. 二.网站各栏目的内容进行了调整. 此
>>在FaceBook中使用Twitter #
近日，各大知名的Blog上都在谈论FaceBook新发布的F8这个平台，这是一个方便集成第三方应用服务到Fackbook的中间平台，将向第三方软件开发者开放诸多核心功能。... 继续.